Every parent, teacher, and therapist working with kids who have ADHD has faced the frustration of traditional discipline falling flat. You issue a consequence, expecting it to deter future misbehavior, but instead, the cycle repeats. The truth is, ADHD isn’t a knowledge problem—it’s a performance problem. Kids with ADHD know what they’re supposed to do; they just struggle to do it in the moment. And this is exactly why punitive measures, like taking away privileges or issuing time-outs, often fail.
Connor Green, a specialist in ADHD behaviors, breaks it down simply: ADHD is a disorder of executive function, which means it affects the brain’s ability to regulate actions, emotions, and impulses. When a child acts out, it’s not because they don’t understand the rules—it’s because their brain isn’t giving them the pause needed to think before acting.
Understanding the ADHD Brain
The frontal lobe, responsible for executive function, is the control center of the brain. It helps with impulse control, planning, and regulating emotions. But in kids with ADHD, this system is inefficient, making it difficult for them to stop and consider consequences before acting. This is why they often appear impulsive, forgetful, or inattentive—not because they don’t care, but because their brains operate differently.
Traditional discipline relies on the assumption that a child will reflect on a punishment and make a better choice next time. However, children with ADHD live in the now. Future consequences feel abstract, making punishments ineffective in changing long-term behavior.
Motivation and the ADHD Child
Neurotypical individuals are often motivated by rewards, importance, and consequences. Kids with ADHD, on the other hand, are motivated by:
Interest (Is this engaging to me?)
Novelty (Is this new or different?)
Challenge (Is this exciting or stimulating?)
Urgency (Is this happening right now?)
Passion (Do I deeply care about this?)
Delayed consequences, like grounding a child for a week, are too far removed from the moment of action to create change. Instead, immediate and meaningful interventions are needed.
What Actually Works?
1. See Behavior as Communication
Behavior is a signal of an unmet need. Instead of focusing on stopping the behavior, shift to asking, What is this behavior telling me? For example, a child smashing a TV in frustration isn’t just “acting out.” They’re showing an inability to regulate big emotions. Addressing the underlying cause—rather than simply punishing the reaction—creates lasting change.
2. Co-Regulation Before Problem-Solving
When a child is dysregulated, their thinking brain is offline. Expecting them to reason in the heat of the moment is like asking someone in a panic attack to “just calm down.” Instead, offer support first. This could look like:
Sitting quietly with them
Offering a preferred activity to help them regulate
Using humor or connection to diffuse tension
Only once they’re calm should problem-solving begin.
3. Comic Strip Conversations
Jessica Canacott, Clinical Director of Just Bee Collective uses comic strips to help with memory processing. This strategy, often used for kids with autism but equally effective for ADHD, helps children visualize what happened leading up to an incident. By drawing out the sequence of events, children can see patterns and make connections between triggers and alternative responses. The key is focusing on what happened before the behavior rather than fixating on the reaction itself.
4. Apology Letters with a Purpose
Rather than forcing a generic “I’m sorry,” guide kids through a reflective apology:
What happened? (State the facts.)
Why did it happen? (What need wasn’t met?)
What can I do differently next time? (Plan for future success.)
This shifts the focus from shame to problem-solving, helping children internalize lessons in a way that punitive measures never could.
Natural Consequences Over Punishment
If a child with ADHD breaks something in frustration, the natural consequence might be working with you to replace or fix it. If they struggle with remembering homework, setting up a system to support their executive functioning is more helpful than punishing forgetfulness. Instead of assuming defiance, assume a skills gap and work together to close it.
The Role of Connection
Punishment can damage the child-adult relationship, creating resistance rather than cooperation. Research and experience show that strong, connected relationships are the foundation for behavioral change. Children who feel seen, heard, and understood are far more likely to accept guidance and develop self-regulation skills.
Parenting and Teaching with Boundaries (Not Punishments)
Clear, consistent boundaries provide safety and predictability. The key is to set expectations beforehand and adjust support based on the child's needs in the moment. For example, Jessica Cannacot suggests “We wash our hands before eating” is a non-negotiable, but how a child does it might be flexible—some may need hand wipes instead of dealing with a crowded, overstimulating bathroom.
Similarly, if a child is struggling with aggression at school, the immediate school consequence (like a suspension) might be unavoidable, but at home, the focus should be on understanding the breakdown and building skills to handle conflicts differently in the future.
Final Thoughts
Kids with ADHD are not trying to be difficult. They are living in a world that often misunderstands their needs and expects them to operate in ways their brains don’t support. When we replace punishment with connection, skill-building, and natural consequences, we set them up for long-term success—not just compliance in the moment.
As Connor Green coaches, true behavioral change happens when we work with the child’s brain, not against it. And as Robyn Gobel reminds us, “Regulate. Relate. Reason.” Punishment skips the first two steps, but when we get those right, the third falls into place naturally.
Learn more about parenting ADHD from Connor Greene https://youtu.be/NKeqzDPunAU?si=u-jq4vtJkXydBSfJ
*Alexa Griffith, LMHC, LCAC, NCC, RPT is a Licensed Mental Health Therapist. Alexa enjoys providing individual counseling and family counseling. She also provides play therapy for children, as well as teen and adolescent counseling via telehealth or in office. Alexa's practice serves the Indianapolis area, including Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Zionsville, and Westfield. Learn more at AlexaGTherapy.com
Comments